*WARNING: This Thread Contains Rambling. While this trait was made quaint & famous by Mark Twain, many studies have linked this southern flavor to interbreeding, preaching, and cancer.
I get my Conspiracy Gene honest. I'm an Agnostic, philosophically, and socially I'm an Atheist. I approach anything that costs me in some way (financially, mentally, emotionally, etcetera) with an appropriate level of skepticism.
I remember my father telling me his theories of the universe. Specifically, he knew that the first Chain-Letters were created by the U.S. Post Office to increase stamp sales. This Government Stamp Conspiracy resurged when email became popular. He had tickets on a million other dark plots. I enjoy spreading these entertaining antidotes when the opportunity naturally arises.
Anytime I come across something new I play at tracing the string of events back to some stratagem. As a historian I enjoy the research, although it's rare to find objectionable-dirt, I always learn something interesting.
A friend of mine is an Alien Conspiracy theorist, so we make a good pair. He believes that Aliens are among us, and that The Government is hiding it at Area 51. My response is generally, 'That's what they want you to think, since Area 51 is where The Government faked the moon landing.' ;)
I don't have any faith in Conspiracy theories, but some of them effectively stir up my skepticism.
When I was in the military, I hung out with the eggheads; I'm a jock that finds librarians sexy. I'm a genus, but not the kind I want to be. I'm a killer-calculator; give me a sharp stick and a target and I'll find a clear path through the odds.
It was at a particular post that I drove for a fellow Trekie; I was the red-shirt and he the gold. On the way back to base, he and his landing party wanted *coffee and invited me to sit with them.
Over coffee we discussed the various aliens, spaceships, and physics of Star Trek(c), and ended up talking about current technologies and prospects. This is when they hit me with the FAKE MOON LANDING Conspiracy.
I'm still not sure if they were jerking my chain, or if they really believed it. They knew all kinds of contradictions and cover-ups. By the time I reached the bottom of my second cup, I was no longer a Moon Landing believer. However! I am still not a Moon Landing Denier.
I find that the anti-evidence (while much of it weak) presents a course of history that is not particularly extraordinary.
I'm a historian these days ("Historians Can Always Find A Date"), with a military history focus. I am a "USS Maine" Denier (Government Conspiracy that instigated the Spanish-American War through popular support and 'yellow journalism').
There are a thousand other aspects of history that are not exactly in alignment with the memory of modern civilizations. Considering the climate during the Kennedy Era. Nations were on the verge of chaos because they feared "the other guys" were going to get Missiles into space first. I don't think it blasphemous to say that governments, like individuals, act in their own perceived best interests (correct or otherwise). If I were locked in a room with hostiles, then I would feel justified in lies that gave advantage.
[takes deep breath] Kennedy almost started WWIII because he put missiles in Turkey, which made the Russians put missiles in Cuba, which lead to a War Countdown, which made JFK pull the missiles out of Turkey, which obligated the Russians to pull theirs out of Cuba, which inspired the people to celebrate the abilities of the President to get them out of danger even though he got them in the danger. So I don't trust the word of Presidents, just because they're president.
Therefore, I honestly call myself a skeptic on many aspects of modern history. Yes, I want to believe humans landed on the moon, because I'm a Geek at heart. I don't necessarily believe there's any justifiable evidence on either side, but I won't panic if another country makes it back to the moon (China) and finds/does-not-find our stuff.
9-11 Conspiracy; well, it reminds me of the Spanish-American War Conspiracy. Americans had to have their Coffee Sugared, just as we need our gas-guzzlers. If it's true, which I don't think it is, then it's one of a number of examples in which leaders destroyed their stuff and blamed it on "the other guys."
While I am shamed by the abilities and embarrassments of our Commander and Chief, I like to think optimistically. Most people are not aware of themselves or their honest motivations, but we want to be good and productive (whether achieved or not). So I don't think that anyone planned the Twin Tower attack except Religious Fundamentalists. But, I won't be in a panic if the 2075 American History Textbook (grades 9-10) says that it was a Government Conspiracy. However, I will be VERY surprised if it turned out to be Jewish Reptilian Aliens.
Kings of History are famous for pulling wool with style and ineptitude.
[enter stage right]Tricky-Dick "I'm not a Crook" Nixon's Plumbers…[exit stage left]
Anyway, I think the guys on the Atheist Experience (Conspiracy : *Episode 534) were too hard on the Moon Landing & 9-11 Deniers. I'm now an Agnostic about these things. My friends think I'm a Moon-Landing denier, but I'm not. Nor am I a Bush-Basher; as when the tide turned I went from being a president basher to a president upholder. I stayed neutral on the abilities of "W," such that; he not bright or articulate and he's one of the top-10 worst American presidents.
Long story short (too late), I consider myself a rational individual about most things. I am reserved in varying degrees depending upon proclamations divided by the evidence. I therefore object to the portrayal of Conspiracies & their Deniers as 'touched.' Sure, most of them are, and the vast majority of their schemes are cracked. BUT! Sometimes, it pays to listen to the jester and/or the madman.
I'm not a Man of Science, but I'm a fan of that Man. If a guy in a lab coat tells me that because X, Y, & Z equal 3.14159 in Spandextivity (insert: Sci-talk), so therefore I should shave my head in combat scenarios to keep little particles of agent from tracking me back to sanctuary, then I would shave my head without further inquiry. While I shave, I might wonder if this is some sort of egg-head joke, but the cost/gain analysis errs on the side of my own best interests.
I think it's healthy to keep a skeptical eye on the governments of man. These Deniers serve us by producing a mad plethora of modern fairytales. Some of which may be based in actual events; Hollywoodized. They certainly produce more fruit than the religiously motivated, and with manna that is easier to swallow as well.
Does anyone else know what I'm talking about? Come on, stop parking. Puff-Puff-Pass…
Sinisterly,
GreenMagi
P.S.
*Episode 534 - http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=666395447802439117
*When the Crusaders introduced Coffee to Europe, the Church thought it the Drink of Satan. Generally, what do people do at Coffee Houses? They discuss Politics, Religion, and Philosophy; all three being judiciously guarded by the Church. But once they recognized that they could either change their position or be ignored, the Pope quickly denied the Devil its drink, and baptized Coffee in the name of our Lord. The End.